09 February 2016

Today's Read: Anna and the Swallow Man by Gavriel Savit

Review: Anna and the Swallow Man by Gavriel SavitWhat if you were seven years old in a war-torn land and suddenly found yourself all alone? Anna ended up on the sidewalk outside the apothecary shop near her apartment in Krakow. The year was 1939, and she had only a vague notion of the war her father had talked about.

When Anna Lania woke on the morning of the sixth of November in the year 1939—her seventh—there were several things that she did not know:

Anna did not know that the chief of the Gestapo in Occupied Poland had by fiat compelled the rector of the Jagiellonian University to require the attendance of all professors (of whom her father was one) at a lecture and discussion on the direction of the Polish Academy under German Sovereignty, to take place at noon that day.

She did not know that, in the company of his colleagues, her father would be taken from lecture hall number 56, first to a prison in Krakow, where they lived, and subsequently to a number of other internment facilities across Poland, before finally being transported to the Sachsenhausen concentration camp in Germany.
Anna and the Swallow Man by Gavriel Savit (Alfred A. Knopf, 2016, p. 1; uncorrected proofs)

Quick Facts
  • Setting: Poland, Germany, Russia, 1939 to about 1944
  • Circumstances: After her father is taken away without warning, Anna falls in with a mysterious man she calls "Swallow Man." His strategy for survival is to keep moving, never be recognized, never make friends. He had no intention of taking Anna under his wing, but she proves useful to many of his schemes for crossing borders and avoiding arrest. A few years into their partnership, they take up with a Jewish musician, who irrevocably changes Anna and the Swallow Man's relationship. They do what they must to survive, but each one also tries to hold on to at least a piece of what he or she once was. 
  • Genre: literary fiction. Some might argue that this is historical fiction, which I guess is true because it's set during World War II.
  • Audience: For some unfathomable reason, Knopf is billing this for ages 12+. Um, no. This is a fully adult novel. I can't imagine that children, or even teens, would grasp all there is in this book.
  • Characters: Anna, a girl with no family or home; Swallow Man, who takes Anna with him on the road; Reb Hirschl, who escaped the ghetto with only his clarinet; various people and soldiers they meet on the road
  • What to say: I'm not at all sure how to discuss this beautifully written and many layered novel. The whole book has a dreamlike quality to it, befitting of Anna, who was unintentionally abandoned and who then lived in near isolation from the rest of the world. All she knows is what she learned from her father and Swallow Man. The dream is, however, periodically punctured by the bald face of reality, and each hole threatens to destroy Anna and Swallow Man's cape of invisibility. 
  • Book club alert: The only way I can write about this book without completely giving everything away is to tell you this is the ultimate book club pick. There is so much to talk about and think about. First there's Swallow Man: Who is he, why is he in permanent hiding, why does he take care of Anna, and why does he allow Reb Hirschl to come along? Anna: The slow erosion of her innocent vision of the world around her is heartbreaking, but she seems strong, especially as she absorbs Swallow Man's lessons. But, we ask, Is she a true survivor and can she remain safe? Then there's Reb Hirschl, a character I didn't like at all. Yet his presence and attitudes and decisions will prompt discussion, especially if you disagree with him on a few key points.
  • The end: Let's just say that I had to read it twice and then discuss it via email with my friend Jill of Rhapsody in Books. We mostly agreed about what happens to the characters at the end, but we saw things slightly differently. Besides the end, we discussed some of the bigger issues and implications about the characters and were definitely on similar tracks. Finally, we were solidly united in thinking this is in no way a children's book.
  • Recommendation: Gavriel Savit's Anna and the Swallow Man is one of the most affecting books I've read in a long time. I can't stop thinking about it and wanting to talk about it. I almost didn't read the novel because I'm getting a little burned out on World War II stories, but this is something completely different. I urge you to give it a try and then please let me know how you interpreted the ending.


Sarah (Sarah's Book Shelves) 2/9/16, 7:50 AM  

I really loved that intro and obviously your glowing comments help too! Despite all that, I was about to say I wouldn't continue solely b/c I'm completely burned out of WWII novels...then I read your last paragraph. So, maybe!

Laura Thomas 2/9/16, 7:53 AM  

I'm with Sarah, and then that last bit! The title is intriguing too.

My TT - http://fuonlyknew.com/2016/02/09/teaser-tuesdays-146-allies-and-enemies-storm-of-arranon-3/

Kay 2/9/16, 8:03 AM  

Yes, I do think many of us have almost burned out on WWII. That being said, your praises of this book are very enticing. Will keep it in mind. Although I'm not really a fan of the ambiguous ending. I like to 'know'. LOL

Majanka Verstraete 2/9/16, 8:06 AM  

This doesn't sound like a children's book at all, but it does sound VERY intriguing. I'll have to keep this book in mind.

Here's my teaser.

JoAnn 2/9/16, 8:29 AM  

This sounds wonderful! Surprised to hear they are marketing it to a 12+ audience though. I'm adding it to my wish list.

(Diane) Bibliophile By the Sea 2/9/16, 8:36 AM  

It's a good intro, however, I try to avoid books set in this time period. The market is oversaturated with the IMO.

rhapsodyinbooks 2/9/16, 9:17 AM  

This is such an outstanding book and I had so much fun discussing it with you - I hope book clubs pick it up . . . which may be difficult since subsequent to reading it I have seen it in three different bookstores in the young adult section. As you said, that's just crazy!

rhonda 2/9/16, 9:34 AM  

Sounds like something I &my book club would find very interesting perfect for conversation

bermudaonion 2/9/16, 9:39 AM  

My sister loved this too - it sounds like I need to pick it up soon.

Kathy Martin 2/9/16, 9:41 AM  

Sounds interesting but very intense. The teaser on my adult blog comes from A Voice from the Field by Neal Griffin. Happy reading!

Paulita 2/9/16, 10:50 AM  

I really feel for the little girl. Here's Mine

Literary Feline 2/9/16, 11:32 AM  

My heart already aches for that little girl. I can't even imagine! You do have me curious about this one. I like to read books set around the World Wars. I will have to look for it.

Laurel-Rain Snow 2/9/16, 12:15 PM  

I love books that leave me with questions that lead to conversations with other readers. Thanks for sharing what sounds like a powerful book...and I agree that it doesn't sound like a book for children.

Thanks for visiting my blog.

Ms. M. 2/9/16, 12:17 PM  

Great teaser. Sounds like a really great book. Thanks for stopping by my blog earlier to see me teaser: http://wp.me/p4DMf0-1aM

Margot 2/9/16, 12:47 PM  

I've also grown tired of World War II stories. Your recommendation to book clubs makes me think I should take a second look.

sjhigbee 2/9/16, 1:05 PM  

It is clearly a really powerful story - I've recently read 'The Puppet Boy of Warsaw' and enjoyed that. Thank you for sharing, it looks worth putting on my TBR pile... This is my TT, which is something of a contrast:

Sandra Nachlinger 2/9/16, 2:13 PM  

This sounds like a fascinating book. The fact that you read it twice tells me that there's a lot to absorb! I'm definitely adding this to my TBR list, even though I imagine it's a difficult story to read.
Thank you for visiting my blog today.

Cleo Bannister 2/9/16, 2:39 PM  

I really, really like the sound of this one - it's going on the TBR

Tribute Books Mama 2/9/16, 3:02 PM  

I would love to read this, thanks! for sharing.

Nise' 2/9/16, 5:18 PM  

I saw this one in a magazine and definitely want to read the book.

Donna H 2/9/16, 6:25 PM  

This sounds like a great read. I agree with you about feeling burned out on WWII stories. I wonder why there was been such a number of notable novels set during this time period of late. Girl Who Reads

(Diane) bookchickdi 2/9/16, 10:23 PM  

Wow, what a rave. I must get this one.

Daryl 2/10/16, 10:36 AM  

While this is not necessarily my cuppa, i cant help but be curious given your review ...

Thanks for stopping by. I read all comments and may respond here, via e-mail, or on your blog. I visit everyone who comments, but not necessarily right away.

I cannot turn off word verification, but if you are logged into Blogger you can ignore the captcha. I have set posts older than 14 days to be on moderation. I can no longer accept anonymous comments. I'm so sorry if this means you have to register or if you have trouble commenting.


All content and photos (except where noted) copyright © cbl for Beth Fish Reads 2008-2016. All rights reserved.



To The Blogger Guide, Blogger Buster, Tips Blogger, Our Blogger Templates, BlogU, and Exploding Boy for the code for customizing my blog. To Old Book Illustrations for my ID photo. To SEO for meta-tag analysis. To Blogger Widgets for the avatars in my comments and sidebar gadgets. To Review of the Web for more gadgets. To SuziQ from Whimpulsive for help with my comments section. To Cool Tricks N Tips for my Google +1 button.

Quick Linker



  © Blogger template Coozie by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP