12 March 2015

Review: Seraphina by Rachel Hartman

Seraphina by Rachel HartmanSometime in the past, in an alternate history, humans and dragons live together, keeping the peace under an uneasy treaty. Some dragons have chosen to live in their own lands, but others, the Saar, have learned to take a human shape and hold positions at court and as teachers.

As the fortieth anniversary of the treaty approaches, the murder of the crown prince of Goredd threatens to irrevocably shatter the tenuous bonds between the species. Popular human opinion has it that dragons are responsible for the death, and prejudice and hate rise to the surface.

The eponymous heroine of Rachel Hartman's Seraphina finds herself unexpectedly at the forefront of the unrest. As the eldest daughter of the treaty's author, Seraphina knows the law. But that's not why, at age sixteen, she has come to court. She is there to assist the royal musician and to provide lessons to the new heir apparent, Princess Glisselda. Seraphina, however, has secrets, and those secrets just might hold the key to a lasting peace.

It's easy to see why Seraphina earned so many awards and starred reviews. Although the idea of dragons and humans living in close proximity is not new, Hartman has given us a fresh take on the theme and a strong, smart main character. Seraphina doesn't always make wise decisions, but she doesn't approach life recklessly. She has talents, but she is also flawed and struggles with self-acceptance.

I chose to listen to the unabridged audiobook read by Mandy Williams. Despite being an avid audiobook fan, I think Serphina is one of those novels that should be read in print. Or perhaps it was that Williams was not a good match for Seraphina.

My primary issue with the audiobook is that Seraphina is old enough to leave home and work in a prestigious position at court. She is intelligent, thoughtful, and troubled. Unfortunately, Williams's voice sounded much too young for the character, which strained my ability to believe in the story. I often had to step back from the audio to remind myself that Seraphina was not twelve.

Although Seraphina is a fantasy, the novel touches on several deeper themes that resonate in modern times. The most important of which are prejudice against those who are different and the problems faced by people of mixed heritages. You see, Seraphina is an abomination and is thought impossible to even exist: her mother, who died in childbirth, was a dragon, but her father is all too human.

In one scene that would have been gut-wrenching in print, Williams fails to convey the depth of Seraphina's self-loathing and utter despair at the physical reminders of her dragon heritage. This same issue is found in the dramatic action scenes. Williams's narration is a little flat, and she would have served listeners better by increasing her pace and sharpening her tones to help us relate to Seraphina's fear and bravery.

Seraphina has a reputation of being a talented musician with an arresting singing voice, and I love that Williams, who has a nice voice, chose to break into song whenever Seraphina performs for an audience. This was a welcome treat, although I'd be remiss not to mention that when singing, Williams came out of character, sounding older and dropping Seraphina's accent.

Recommendation: Seraphina is a complex novel with a likable, smart, and flawed heroine. Rachel Hartman has created a unique, yet familiar world in which beings are struggling to understand each other and to find a middle ground in which both sides can embrace their differences. Even the obligatory love story is realistic and slow-building. Hartman has nicely balanced the action, the world building, and the characters' personal stories. Seraphina well deserves its awards and rave reviews.

Unfortunately, the audiobook does not do this novel justice. My suggestion is to stick with print. I understand that the print book contains a glossary and a list of characters. It's too bad these materials were not available as PDF downloads for listeners.

Note: Veteran narrator Justin Eyre has minor role in Seraphina. Her performance was well done. For a sample of Mandy Williams's performance, hit the play button in the widget below.

Print: Random House Books for Young Readers, 2012
ISBN-13: 9780375866562
Audio: Listening Library; 13 hr, 15 min
Source: Review (audio) (see review policy)
Copyright © cbl for Beth Fish Reads, all rights reserved (see review policy)


Amanda 3/12/15, 8:19 AM  

Hm. When I saw you had this out I was hoping you'd say the audio was good, because it's been so long since I read Seraphina that I think I need to revisit it before I read Shadow Scale. I'll check out the sample you included, but I have a feeling that reread will be in print!

rhapsodyinbooks 3/12/15, 8:46 AM  

How odd about the narrator. I loved this book (in print). Narrators can definitely make a difference!

bermudaonion 3/12/15, 9:00 AM  

I'm just not into dragons but my sister loves them. I think she loved this book too.

Haley 3/12/15, 2:04 PM  

I LOVE this book and can't wait to read Shadow Scale. I recently re-read it and it was just as good as I remembered from reading it a couple years ago. Hartman does an incredible job of not just creating an entertaining and suspenseful story, but inventing a whole world, religion, culture that completely immerses the reader.

Charlie (The Worm Hole) 3/12/15, 2:38 PM  

I intend to get to this book at some point, hopefully sooner rather than later. For what you've said, definitely in print!

Kailana 3/12/15, 10:12 PM  

I was thinking about rereading Seraphina in audio, but now I think I will stick to a print reread!

Belle Wong 3/13/15, 1:04 AM  

Seraphina is in my TBR - I have it in ebook format, not audio. It sounds like that's definitely the way to go with this one.

Daryl 3/13/15, 12:44 PM  

sounds intriguing putting it on my later list

Laura at Library of Clean Reads 3/14/15, 12:04 PM  

It's true that if a voice does not match well with the character especially when of a certain age it will be a struggle for our minds that somehow knows exactly how to voice that character.

Julie P. 3/20/15, 8:38 AM  

Thanks for sharing. I was wondering about this book and now I know to read it in print!

Thanks for stopping by. I read all comments and may respond here, via e-mail, or on your blog. I visit everyone who comments, but not necessarily right away.

I cannot turn off word verification, but if you are logged into Blogger you can ignore the captcha. I have set posts older than 14 days to be on moderation. I can no longer accept anonymous comments. I'm so sorry if this means you have to register or if you have trouble commenting.


All content and photos (except where noted) copyright © cbl for Beth Fish Reads 2008-2020. All rights reserved.



To The Blogger Guide, Blogger Buster, Tips Blogger, Our Blogger Templates, BlogU, and Exploding Boy for the code for customizing my blog. To Old Book Illustrations for my ID photo. To SEO for meta-tag analysis. To Blogger Widgets for the avatars in my comments and sidebar gadgets. To Review of the Web for more gadgets. To SuziQ from Whimpulsive for help with my comments section. To Cool Tricks N Tips for my Google +1 button.

Quick Linker



  © Blogger template Coozie by Ourblogtemplates.com 2008

Back to TOP